
You already know hire purchase (HP) is a loan, so I won’t insult your intelligence. What I want to focus on is how it differs from a personal loan, because the two are not the same thing.
What is hire purchase?
HP is a straight loan, normally arranged at the dealership and funded by a finance house. The dealership usually administers it, although you can often go online and arrange finance yourself at a much cheaper rate.
The main advantage is that you own the car at the end. There’s no purchase fee and no balloon payment. Once you’ve made the final payment, the car is yours. There are also:
- No mileage restrictions.
- No restrictions on what you do with the car, including taking it abroad.
- Fixed monthly payments, which in my experience is how every HP deal has worked.
The only rule is that you keep making the payments. It’s the most straightforward structure in car finance.
HP is available on new and used cars, although lenders can have conditions. Typically a car needs to be under around 10 years old and under 100,000 miles, much like extended warranties. With so many older used cars on the road it’s probably easier than ever to find finance, but check with your lender.
HP versus PCP
On the whole, HP is cheaper than PCP in the interest you pay, which I cover in my PCP guide. The catch is that the monthly payments are usually higher, because you aren’t offsetting part of the cost with a balloon. You’re paying interest on the whole balance you’re funding.
The tripartite agreement
Something that doesn’t get talked about much is that HP is a tripartite agreement: three parties are involved, the dealer selling you the car, you, and the finance company. Until you’ve paid for it, the car is effectively the finance company’s.
That means if something goes wrong and the dealer can’t settle a dispute, the finance company can get involved, because they have an interest in the car. If you’re one individual up against a dealer or manufacturer with more money and legal resources, it can help to have a finance company’s legal department on your side. I rarely saw it happen, but it’s an extra layer of security you don’t get with every form of funding.
The downsides of HP
- Most people choose the longest term to get the lowest monthly payment, convincing themselves they’ll keep the car for five years. In reality most people keep their cars two and a half to three years at most. Many of the customers who bought on finance came in midway or three-quarters of the way through their agreement and had to settle off the finance first. A long agreement means a shock when you see the cost of getting out.
- You’re responsible for all maintenance and running costs. The finance company only cares about the car if you stop paying and they need to repossess it.
- Repossession risk. The loan is secured on the car, which is why lenders impose conditions on age and mileage.
Hire purchase versus a personal loan
A personal loan from a bank, building society, supermarket or loan company does a similar job, with some key differences.
The loan is unsecured. Repossession of the car isn’t the automatic route if you stop paying. That doesn’t mean the lender won’t come after you for the money, because they will. They don’t mind whether you spend it on a car, a holiday or a bet on the 3:30 at Ascot.
You can shop around. If your credit is good you can find very competitive fixed rates, and online you can have the money in your account within a few minutes of applying. At a dealership you’ll often pay a couple of percentage points more than you would at a bank or building society. If an HP deal at around 6.9–7.2% APR is on offer, it can be competitive with a personal loan, but many aren’t.
You lose the tripartite protection. A personal loan lender won’t step in if something goes wrong with the car.
There’s no voluntary termination right. This matters most in uncertain times. With HP you have a legal right to hand the car back once you’ve paid 50% of the total amount payable, which isn’t half your payments. Say you borrow £10,000 with £2,000 of interest over the term. The total is £12,000, so you’d need to pay just over £6,000 before you could hand it back. A personal loan doesn’t give you that option at all.
Which would I choose?
When I sold finance for a living, I was naturally more interested in HP. I used to favour it for the tripartite agreement and the voluntary termination rights. These days, because I’m more bothered about paying the least interest, I’d lean towards a personal loan, particularly for a used car. HP is convenient, but getting a personal loan isn’t inconvenient any more.
Who is HP best for?
HP is a good option if you want to keep the car for five, six, seven years or longer, or if your mileage is unpredictable, because there’s no limit to worry about. It’s also a good fit if you’re not keen on balloon payments, and it suits you if you’re optimistic about your financial future and don’t expect problems in the next few years.
I still think the payments are on the high side unless you’re buying a cheap car, and how much that matters depends on how much deposit you put in and how much you’re borrowing. For me, there are usually better ways of funding a car, but it’s your call.
This guide is one of four. See also PCP, leasing and paying cash, or the overview of all four ways to pay.
If you’d like independent help with a deal, I offer a car deal consultation service. I work for you, not the dealer. Find out more.