
Between 80 and 90% of new cars bought in this country are paid for using some form of finance. Customers will sometimes tell the dealership otherwise, but after years working in dealerships I can tell you it’s the truth, and the percentage has only been creeping up.
So if you’re about to buy your next car, it pays to know exactly what you’re being offered. There are four main ways to pay for a car in the UK: PCP, leasing (also called personal contract hire), hire purchase and paying cash. Here’s how each one works, and who it suits.
1. PCP (personal contract purchase)
A PCP splits the cost of the car into three parts:
- A deposit, usually a fairly small percentage of the price, paid up front.
- Monthly payments, which cover the car’s depreciation plus interest.
- A final “balloon” payment, often called the guaranteed future value or guaranteed minimum future value (GMFV).
Take a £32,000 car with a £3,200 deposit. That leaves £28,800 to finance. If the finance company sets a £15,000 balloon, your monthly payments only have to cover the difference, which is why they come out lower than on a normal HP deal. One thing that catches people out: you pay interest on the whole £28,800 from day one, even though the balloon isn’t being paid off month by month.
At the end of the agreement you have three choices:
- Pay the balloon and keep the car.
- Hand the car back and walk away (as long as you’ve stayed within the mileage and the car is in fair condition).
- Trade it in. If the car is worth more than the balloon, that difference is yours to use as a deposit on the next one.
The finance company decides how big the balloon is, not you, and it’s based on what they think the car will be worth at the end. PCP is popular because it gets you into a new car for a lower monthly payment. I go into much more detail in my full guide to PCP.
2. Leasing (personal contract hire)
Leasing is the one I use myself. It’s a long-term rental: you pay a deposit (sometimes none at all), then fixed monthly payments, and at the end you hand the car back. There’s no balloon payment and you never own the car, but you get to drive and enjoy it as your own.
Think back to the days when everyone took their mobile phone on a 12 or 24 month contract and couldn’t wait for the next model. A lease works in much the same way, and it’s usually the cheapest way to run a brand new car.
The things to watch are the mileage limit and the condition of the car when you hand it back. It’s assessed by a professional, usually against a fair wear and tear policy. On a car that’s been looked after, two or three years in, any extra charges are usually a couple of hundred pounds at most, but it’s worth knowing what’s allowed before you sign. There are also some good used leases now, particularly on electric cars. More in my guide to car leasing.
3. Hire purchase (HP)
HP is the traditional way of paying for a car, new or used. You put down a deposit, borrow the balance, and make fixed monthly payments until it’s paid off. Then the car is yours, with no balloon and no purchase fee.
There are no mileage restrictions and no fair wear and tear rules to worry about. If you scrape it, that’s between you and your insurer. The trade-off is that HP looks expensive next to the other options, because you’re paying off the whole balance rather than offsetting part of it.
A personal loan from a bank does a similar job, but it isn’t secured on the car, so there are pros and cons to each. I compare them in my guide to hire purchase.
4. Paying cash
“Cash” no longer means a carrier bag of notes. If you tried to pay £30,000 in used notes at a dealership, you’d be asking for a money-laundering investigation. These days paying cash means a bank transfer or a debit card.
If you’ve got the money sitting there and wouldn’t even notice it leaving your account, there’s nothing wrong with it. But for most people, paying outright means putting a lot of money into something that loses value fast. I wouldn’t tell you not to, but there are usually better things to do with your money. I cover this properly in why paying cash isn’t always the smart move.
Which one is right for you?
All four have pros and cons, and your circumstances will decide which suits you. Here’s a quick comparison:
| Deposit | Monthly payments | At the end | |
|---|---|---|---|
| PCP | Small | Low | Pay the balloon, hand back or trade in |
| Leasing | Small or none | Usually the lowest | Hand the car back |
| HP | Any | Higher | You own the car |
| Cash | Full price | None | You own the car |
I’ll add one thing from years in a Land Rover dealership. Around 90% of customers told me they were paying cash and would never take finance. Many of them weren’t, and now and again someone would get caught out because they couldn’t collect their car on handover day: the loan they’d taken out hadn’t landed in their account yet. I’m not saying they were all fibbing, but the national figures speak for themselves.
Go in armed with the facts
Once you know the four options, you can work out roughly what you should be paying before you ever walk into a showroom. That way you won’t be pressured into an agreement that doesn’t suit you, and you won’t be taken in by a salesperson who suddenly “finds” a lower monthly payment once you say the first one is too high.
If you’d like more help, I offer an independent car deal consultation service. I work for you, not the dealer, the manufacturer or the finance company, and I’ll help you with the numbers and the negotiation so you come out with the best deal possible. Find out more about my consultations.